Semantico-pragmatic aspects of the metalinguistic uses of comparatives in Mandarin Chinese and English

Author

Meng Yang

ORCID Identifier(s)

0009-0009-2699-2056

Graduation Semester and Year

2023

Language

English

Document Type

Dissertation

Degree Name

Doctor of Philosophy in Linguistics

Department

Linguistics

First Advisor

Laurel Stvan

Abstract

This dissertation examines a group of Metalinguistic Comparatives (MCs) in Mandarin Chinese, exploring what they suggest about the universality of comparatives. I show that Chinese MCs encode a more fine-grained scalarity of the subjective attitude conveyed, which varies in orientation, i.e., positive or negative, and strength, i.e., subtle or strong. By analyzing their uses in conversational settings, I claim that MCs are pragmatical devices for speakers to reject or rectify an utterance. In examining the shared Chinese ‘than’ marker in both Negative MCs (NegMCs) and Rhetorical Comparatives (RCs), I show that both subtypes are comparatives with a contrastive and negative sense, rather than a description of a degree-differential ordering relation. Furthermore, I propose a Logic Convertibility analysis for comparatives, showing a comparative is logically equivalent to the negation of the flipped inequality relation, i.e., (d1 ? d2) ? NOT (d2 ? d1), which builds the foundation for an implied negative inference to be retrieved. Finally, I suggest English comparatives are pragmatically ambiguous in that they descriptively encode a degree-differential inequality relation but can simultaneously produce a metalinguistic reading, i.e., to convey an evaluative attitude.

Keywords

Metalinguistic comparatives, Rhetorical comparatives, Degree comparatives, Mandarin Chinese, Even, NPI, Negativity

Disciplines

Linguistics | Social and Behavioral Sciences

License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-Share Alike 4.0 International License.

Comments

Degree granted by The University of Texas at Arlington

Recommended Citation

Yang, Meng, "Semantico-pragmatic aspects of the metalinguistic uses of comparatives in Mandarin Chinese and English" (2023). Linguistics & TESOL Dissertations. 115.
https://mavmatrix.uta.edu/linguistics_tesol_dissertations/115